New device for refined neural recording in mice could transform dementia research
NC3Rs funding for inter-disciplinary research which combines electrical engineering and neurophysiology has resulted in a new product for brain recordings in mice that avoids many of the welfare concerns associated with existing approaches.
Research published today in Scientific Reports describes a new ultra lightweight system for recording neural activity in the brains of mice. The device, referred to as TaiNi, has been developed by engineers at Imperial College London in collaboration with pharmaceutical company Lilly’s UK research labs and with funding from the NC3Rs open innovation programme CRACK IT Challenges.
EEG recordings are typically conducted in mice to understand neural activity and how it relates to specific behaviours or cognitive tasks such as memory, learning and decision-making. Such studies are relevant for understanding brain disorders like schizophrenia and Alzheimer’s disease, and typically involve the use of wireless recording devices on the mouse’s head. These are heavy for the mice to carry and have limited battery life. Alternative approaches involve tethered recording systems (see video below) which restrict the mouse’s movement and the testing paradigms they can be used in.
Video taken from paper: Zhou Jiang et al (2017) TaiNi: Maximizing research output whilst improving animals’ welfare in neurophysiology experiments. Scientific Reports doi:10.1038/s41598-017-08078-8.
To address the animal welfare and technical issues associated with existing recording systems, in 2011 the NC3Rs and Lilly posed the Cognition Challenge to the scientific community to develop a lightweight EEG recording device that could be used in awake freely moving unrestrained mice, including in a range of behavioural tests. The £500k contract to solve the Challenge was won by Esther Rodriguez-Villegas, Professor of Low Power Electronics at Imperial College London, whose work is usually focused on low power healthcare applications such as wearable sensors rather than animal welfare.
The TaiNi device (video below) pushes the boundaries of low power electronics (in terms of its size, weight, battery life and signal bandwidth) and has the potential to be transformative both in pharmaceutical and academic research for the study of neural networks.
Video taken from paper: Zhou Jiang et al (2017) TaiNi: Maximizing research output whilst improving animals’ welfare in neurophysiology experiments. Scientific Reports doi:10.1038/s41598-017-08078-8.
The wireless low power device, which weighs just 1.5g, has been trialled in studies at Lilly. It is capable of 72 hours recording from 16 channels and of capturing local field and action potentials from mice performing a range of tasks in a variety of environments, with data synchronisation to behaviour with sub-second precision. Because of its high signal bandwidth, in addition to traditional EEG, TaiNi can also monitor networks of individual neurons in the brain. This greatly increases the amount of information gathered from each mouse every time a recording is made.
As shown in the video, it also offers significant animal welfare benefits which include maintaining the normal repertoire of movement and behaviours which are not possible with other wireless and tethered systems. Importantly, recordings using the TaiNi device can now be taken in automated testing arenas linked to the animal’s home cage, where mice have a choice of when they perform behavioural tasks, with the advantage of avoiding repeated handling that can be stressful. Such studies could not be performed with tethered mice.
Comparison with other commercially available recording devices and Lilly specifications
|
|
Weight (g) |
Time (hours) |
Channels |
Bandwidth (Hz) |
bit-depth |
Noise (rms) |
|
Lilly system specifications |
||||||
|
Ideal |
3 |
240 |
16 |
10000 |
12 |
~1μV |
|
Absolute limit |
3 |
16 |
16 |
7500 |
10 |
8μV |
|
Commercially available telemetry systems |
||||||
|
TaiNi |
1.5 |
72 |
16 |
0.3-9400 |
12 |
3.9μV |
|
Millar MT10Ba |
2.5 |
N/A |
2 |
2-440 |
12 |
N/A |
|
TBSI W16 |
4.0 |
4.2 |
16 |
0.8-7000 |
16 |
8.3μV |
|
EMKA rodentPACK |
5.2 |
150 |
4 |
1-150 |
12 |
NA |
|
Multichannel systems W2100-HS16 |
6.8 |
1.7 |
16 |
1-5000 |
16 |
1.9μV |
|
Neuralynx CUBE-64 |
17.0 |
0.5 |
64 |
0.1-8000 |
16 |
2.5μV |
|
Pinnacle 8200-K6-SLb |
23.0 |
36 |
3 |
? (<1000) |
12 |
N/A |
|
Dueteron Technologies MouseLog-16c |
2.8 |
9 |
16 |
1-7000 |
N/A |
N/A |
|
TSE systems Neurologgerb,c |
2.5 |
92 |
4 |
? (<250) |
N/A |
N/A |
a inductive charging system (no maximum recording time)
b band-width was not specified in available materials, and is inferred
c data-logger systems (no transmission)
Find out more about TaiNi
If you would like to know more about the TaiNi device please visit tainitec.com
Quotes
Professor Esther Rodriguez-Villegas, Imperial College London
"This has been an incredibly exciting and challenging project pushing the boundaries of microelectronics design and applying it in a truly novel area for us. The project has been a great example of the importance of thinking outside of the box to find solutions to research problems which will have a massive impact. It has demonstrated that the best solutions often come from unexpected sources and the CRACK IT scheme from the NC3Rs is a great example of how to make this happen."
Dr John Huxter, Principal Pharmacologist, Lilly and industry lead for the Cognition Challenge
"This has been one of the most rewarding projects I've ever participated in, and it is genuinely exciting from a scientific and 3Rs perspective. The TaiNi device is a transformative technology which will open up entirely new areas of investigation and understanding in many brain disorders such as dementia and Alzheimer’s disease."
Dr Anthony Holmes, Head of Technology Development, NC3Rs
"The TaiNi device shows the importance of taking multi-disciplinary approaches to tackling 3Rs challenges. The device will soon be available to purchase ensuring that the animal welfare benefits compared to other recording devices are maximised."
Paper
TaiNi images, videos and table are reproduced from the article referenced below, under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Zhou Jiang, John R. Huxter, Stuart A. Bowyer, Anthony J. Blockeel, James Butler, Syed A. Imtiaz, Keith A. Wafford, Keith G. Phillips, Mark D. Tricklebank, Hugh M. Marston & Esther Rodriguez-Villegas (2017) TaiNi: Maximizing research output whilst improving animals’ welfare in neurophysiology experiments. Scientific Reports doi:10.1038/s41598-017-08078-8.
About CRACK IT Challenges
CRACK IT Challenges is an open innovation R&D competition from the NC3Rs which funds the development and commercialisation of 3Rs products and services. Challenges are developed in partnership with Sponsors who are usually from the pharmaceutical, chemical, agrochemical or consumer product sectors. Sponsors work with SMEs and academics, who are funded by the NC3Rs to solve the Challenges, providing in-kind contributions such as access to compounds, data, equipment or expertise. To date around £17 million has been committed to the CRACK IT Challenges programme. The competition is run using Innovate UK’s Small Business Research Initiative.
Further information on CRACK IT can be found here.